Wednesday, February 4, 2009

The Curious Case Of How to Make an Award Winner

So I paid my usually ten bucks, but for this film I thought it would be worth it. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button had so much hype and Brad Pitt attached to it. But when I sat down and sat through this 3 hour sob job I felt like David Fincher ate Forrest Gump and shit out a terrible and more handicapped version. If David Fincher walked up to a meeting with the producers in Paramount Pictures executive suite and they handed him a guide on how-to-win an Oscar and a check for a trillion dollars fresh from the bailout plan, I would be far from surprised. 
I felt that Pitt handled his performance well but most of it was in heavy makeup and CGI effects. There was no high point or reason to cringe or cry, a lack of a climactic moment left me wondering when this movie was going to end. If Brad Pitt really wants to challenge himself he should talk to DiCaprio's agent. Blanchett did show her talents and experience though. I have to admit that she was definitely a light amongst the otherwise dismal scene. 
Maybe it was the hype that lead me to be so critical of this film, because once I got over my initial anger I did really enjoy bits and pieces of it. The character played by Jared Harris as Captain Mike was my favorite. He had true depth to him and his performance was hilarious. Another point of criticism is the fact that the adaptation from F. Scott Fitzgerald's short story of the same name, wasn't even close. It would be like a screenwriter adapting Harry Potter and making Jumper. Eric Roth took the unique idea of backwards aging and ran with it, in the wrong direction like the special kid on the football field.
David Fincher, known for his hard hitting gritty film style decided for this movie that he would detach his balls, dip them in the sappy vat of Hollywood's knack for bloating everything up and essentially destroying the minimalist effect of simple art. Visually it was stunning and if i watched this film on mute i would be pleased by his achievements, but in conjunction with the story it felt unnecessary. The world he created was much to spanning and the effect was lost. 
Overall this film had such incredible potential being born from an F. Scott Fitzgerald story, but it fell in all the wrong places. I wouldn't say it was a complete failure or basically Gigli 2, but i would say that where it needed to shine it didn't. David Fincher became like a child with a new toy and was almost showing off his ability to make things look nice. The visual achievements are great in their own right but within the context of the film they were not only over done but almost formulaic, as if he knew he was attempting to make an Oscar buzz-worthy film.

No comments:

Post a Comment